EDL subsystem engineering rules
The following rules should be followed during the design and development of an EDL system.
On the vehicle and system design:
- Keep it simple, it is already hard enough
- First make it fly, then make it better
- [alternative] If a system does not work, you cannot make it better
- An overly complex system is only good as a museum piece
- Keep track of requirements, even if only used to establish a clear line of blame
- Do not change the requirements without consulting the entire team. Or just do not change the requirements
- Assume everything goes wrong
- [alternative] Plan for the worst, prepare for the worst, assume the worst
- When implemented wrongly, redundancy reduces the probability of mission success
- When designing a system keep producibility and testability in mind
On systems engineering:
- Every system you include requires introduces additional V and V
- Every system you include introduces interfaces, which require additional V and V
- [alternative] If you do not need a subsystem, do not include it
- Just because you can, does not mean you should
- Find a solution that works, even if it is not the best
- The optimal solution is always in the middle and never at an extreme
- Mechanical and electrical engineers do not speak the same language. Find a systems engineer to translate
- The most important person in your team is the person responsible for Assembly Integration and Testing (AIT)
- If you do not have an AIT person, good luck
- Test as you fly and fly as you test
- Test test and test again
- [alternative] If you think you have tested enough, test again
- Keep the number of interfaces to a minimum
- Interfaces with external parties count as ten interfaces
On (EDL) simulations:
- Every model is wrong, it is up to the engineer to accept how wrong a model can be
- Monte Carlo is a simulation engineer’s best friend
On atmospheric entry:
- If your vehicle gets too hot, play with the ballistic coefficient
- The ballistic coefficient is an entry engineer’s best friend
On parachute systems:
- If somebody claims to be a parachute expert, he is not
- The smaller the parachute, the larger the accuracy needed to keep it stable
- Stable cross parachutes do not exist
- [After seeing a stable cross in the wind tunnel] Even cross parachutes can be tamed
- If an unstable parachute is stable in flight, it is not stable it just glides
- Avoid supersonic inflation
- If supersonic parachute inflation cannot be avoided, avoid transonic parachute inflation
- If transonic parachute inflations are unavoidable, change your ballistic coefficient. And see the above two rules
On landing systems:
- Do not forget the landing system